Marvel’s decision to reintroduce Chris Evans’ character Steve Rogers in Avengers: Doomsday has prompted backlash online, with many fans criticizing the move as a “desperate” attempt to win back audiences at the expense of newer characters, and especially Anthony Mackie’s Sam Wilson.
Today’s Avengers: Doomsday trailer, which is available to watch now in theaters attached to Avatar: Fire and Ash, confirms what had previously been leaked: that Marvel has more story to tell featuring Steve Rogers, following what appeared to be a final send-off to the character in Avengers: Endgame.
One of Endgame’s most memorable scenes saw Steve passing his shield to Sam, physically handing over the mantle of Captain America as he bowed out of the role. Now, fans say, this moment has effectively been undone, with numerous comments calling it a snub both to Sam, and to Mackie’s tenure.
“The MCU just keeps on disrespecting Sam Wilson and I am TIREDDD,” wrote one fan on X. “It feels like Marvel is belittling Sam Wilson’s efforts to prove himself worthy of the shield Steve passed on to him,” added another, sharing a clip of Sam’s training from Disney+ series The Falcon and the Winter Soldier.
“All I have to say about Avengers: Doomsday is that I will not tolerate the Sam Wilson disrespect!” added another. “What is the point! That whole ass movie about exactly this scenario only for them to bring back Steve anyway????!”
Numerous comments have pointed to the tough journey Sam Wilson has faced since being given the shield by Steve. The Falcon and the Winter Soldier effectively negates Steve’s decision by placing a question mark on Sam’s claim (and personal desire) to be Cap, only for him to emerge as the hero by the series’ end.
Mackie’s only lead movie in the years since, Captain America: Brave New World, was then widely panned by critics and fans alike for its underwhelming and heavily-reshot story, though many still praised Mackie’s performance as the actor doing the best he could with the material he was given. (In IGN’s 5/10 Captain America: Brave New World review, we described the movie as “neither brave, nor all that new, falling short of strong performances from Anthony Mackie, Harrison Ford, and Carl Lumbly.”)
Regardless, Marvel boss Kevin Feige subsequently raised eyebrows by subsequently pinning the film’s financial failure on being “the first without Chris Evans.” No plans have since been announced for a fresh Captain America sequel.
Alongside criticism specifically of Steve Rogers’ former Captain America returning, more general disdain has been expressed at Marvel yet again returning to a name from the franchise’s Infinity Saga, after previously casting former Iron Man star Robert Downey Jr. as Doctor Doom. It’s a point of discussion that IGN itself has picked up, and dubbed as a “surprisingly disappointing way of kicking off the film’s marketing.” As IGN’s Jesse Schedeen states, “Why is a movie that’s supposed to bring together the current generation of MCU heroes so preoccupied with the former Captain America?”
“They spent six years introducing new characters only to do this,” wrote a fan with a similar view on X, labelling the decision as “pathetic and desperate.”
“Y’all bashed Eternals, Marvels, Fantastic Four, Multiverse of Madness, etc,” another fan countered. “Now y’all complaining about bringing back the OGs. Anything Marvel does will be considered pathetic and desperate.”
While the many Marvel releases since Avengers: Endgame have been mixed in quality, and nothing has come close to rivalling that movie’s enormous $2.8 billion box office haul, the MCU has still had some notable successes. Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness earned $955 million, while Black Panther: Wakanda Forever drew in $859 million. Deadpool and Wolverine, meanwhile, made over $1.38 billion.
Still, it’s notable that Marvel seems keen to market Avengers: Doomsday to the huge audience that turned for Endgame, rather than those who watched anything since. The movie’s big market beats so far have been Downey Jr. getting announced as Doctor Doom, and now Evans getting announced as Steve Rogers (whether he ends up as Captain America again, or not).
A leaked plan for three more Avengers: Doomsday trailers has suggested that yet another OG Avengers actor, Chris Hemsworth, will be given his own trailer next, before a trailer that fully reveals Downey Jr. as Doom follows that. Only after all of those, will the movie get a more general trailer — which may be where we finally see more of Marvel’s current roster.
Tom Phillips is IGN’s News Editor. You can reach Tom at [email protected] or find him on Bluesky @tomphillipseg.bsky.social
