Nintendo has finally won damages in a Wii Remote lawsuit it’s been fighting since 2010, over an unofficial controller that infringed on the company’s patents.
15 years on, Nintendo has claimed victory in its extremely long-running battle against Bigben Interactive (since renamed Nacon), and has been awarded a judgment worth $7 million (around $8.2 million). The actual damages Nintendo has been awarded count for around half the amount, while the rest is made up of interest, since the case has dragged on for so long.
Why has it taken a decade and a half to sort? As reported by GamesFray, Nintendo won an early ruling on the case back in 2011, though Nacon has been able to delay a further decision on damages until now. And the matter still isn’t over, as Nacon is now appealing the verdict — holding off on paying for even longer.
Back in 2010, Nintendo said a third-party Wii controller made by Nacon, then Bigben, infringed on its own patents and had caused the company to lose money. Without that third-party controller on the market, Nintendo argued, customers would have otherwise bought more of its official Wii Remote instead.
In response, Bigben said that customers could have chosen other third-party controllers as well as its own, so Nintendo couldn’t claim it would have definitely lost out. But Nintendo ultimately won this argument, as a court decided that the company’s patents were strong enough that no other third-party controller could have been made without others infringing on Nintendo’s patents also.
Nintendo has a reputation for being a litigious company, pursuing video game pirates and instances where it feels its trademarks have been infringed — such as in its current legal action against Palworld maker Pocketpair, which it currently seems to be struggling with.
If nothing else, this latest development shows that Nintendo is nothing if not persistent. And if the company does want to pursue you, prepare to still be fighting, three console generations later.
Tom Phillips is IGN’s News Editor. You can reach Tom at [email protected] or find him on Bluesky @tomphillipseg.bsky.social
